ASOS vs Shopbop: Tops & Knitwear Shopping Guide
Shopping for tops and knitwear? ASOS and Shopbop both deliver, but they're playing different games. ASOS is your fast-fashion playground with affordable trends that move fast; Shopbop is the edit-conscious luxury destination where you're investing in pieces that'll last. Here's how to decide where to spend your money.
ASOS
ASOS moves quick and cheap—great for experimenting with trends and building basics without guilt. You're getting trend-forward pieces that feel current, not timeless.
Miss Selfridge embroidered handkerchief top in white $59.99
Delicate embroidery detail at a price that lets you experiment.
- Best for Layering over a slip dress or wearing solo on a date.
- Wear it with Tuck into high-waisted trousers or wear loose over a camisole.
- Fit Runs true; cotton with embroidered yoke detail, lightweight.
Topshop organza collapsed funnel neck top in oyster $60
That collapsing neckline is architectural without being fussy.
- Best for Office Fridays or dinner with people who notice fabrics.
- Wear it with Pair with tailored trousers and a blazer; the top does the talking.
- Fit Organza gives structure; runs true through the shoulders.
River Island daisy embroidered frill blouse in white $78
Daisy embroidery feels special, but the price keeps it real.
- Best for Weekend dressing, garden parties, any excuse to feel dressed up.
- Wear it with White jeans or a skirt—let the ruffle frill be the moment.
- Fit Cotton blend; slightly cropped through the torso, longer hem.
& Other Stories poplin blouse with puff sleeves in white $96
Puff sleeves done with restraint—Scandi cool, not costume-y.
- Best for When you want structure without loudness; work-to-weekend.
- Wear it with Cream trousers and a simple bag let the sleeves breathe.
- Fit Poplin is crisp; runs true; sleeves have gentle volume at the cap.
Shop & Other Stories poplin blouse with puff sleeves in white →
Cotton On greta frill blouse in vanilla glow $44
Frills at this price point feel like a steal, not a compromise.
- Best for Casual weekends, layering, building a comfortable basic wardrobe.
- Wear it with Oversized over a slip, or tucked into denim for a softer look.
- Fit Soft cotton; generous through the body, ruffled placket adds texture.
AWARE off shoulder ruffle top with smock detail in terracotta $70
Off-shoulder and ruffled, but the smock detail keeps it grounded.
- Best for Warm weather, nights out, when you want romantic without trying too hard.
- Wear it with High-waisted skirt or shorts; minimal jewelry so the top shines.
- Fit Runs true; elastic at the waist gives comfort and shape.
Shop AWARE off shoulder ruffle top with smock detail in terracotta →
Shopbop
Shopbop is a solid place to shop tops & knitwear — these are the pieces worth your time.
POSSE — Darya Top $250
Architectural cut and unexpected proportions—this top earns its price.
- Best for Someone building a considered wardrobe; pieces that mix with everything.
- Wear it with Straight-leg trousers and sneakers; or over a slip skirt for night.
- Fit Contemporary fit; runs true; structured cotton that holds its shape.
Ulla Johnson — Gracie Cotton Top $290
Intricate smocking and cotton lawn fabric feel handmade, not mass-produced.
- Best for Layering under slip dresses, or wearing solo as a statement piece.
- Wear it with Midi skirt or tailored trousers; let the detail be your jewelry.
- Fit Runs true; lawn cotton is delicate; smocking creates gentle structure.
Ulla Johnson — Marnie Cotton Shorts $320
A tops & knitwear piece that earns its place — quietly good, not loud about it.
- Best for Building a wardrobe around one great piece; investment that lasts.
- Wear it with White jeans, neutral bag, let the top do the color work.
- Fit Designed fit; runs true through shoulders; structured cotton poplin.
Tanya Taylor — Adelina Top $345
Geometric cut and unexpected seaming make this feel modern and considered.
- Best for Someone who wants polish without predictability.
- Wear it with Tailored trousers and minimal jewelry; this top needs room to breathe.
- Fit Contemporary cut; runs true; crisp cotton that holds architectural lines.
Tanya Taylor — Fallon Shorts $295
Quality basics that actually last—rag & bone's shorthand is 'designed right.'
- Best for The person who'd rather buy one great piece than ten okay ones.
- Wear it with White shirt with tailored trousers, or tied over a slip dress.
- Fit Clean cut; runs true; structured cotton with a subtle drape.
rag & bone — Nolan Shorts $198
Investment pieces that feel intentional; contemporary cut without trend noise.
- Best for Building a wardrobe you'll reach for in five years.
- Wear it with Paired with tailored bottoms or layered under slip dresses.
- Fit Designed contemporary; runs true; quality construction throughout.
Which should you pick?
Pick ASOS if you want to experiment, have fun with trends, and don't need pieces to last forever—great for basics, seasonal trends, and building confidence. Pick Shopbop if you're investing in tops that'll feel fresh in years, with interesting details and quality that justify the price. Both have their place; it's really about whether you're shopping for now or forever.
See the full list on Benable
See my full tops & knitwear edit on Benable →
Frequently asked questions
Which site has better sizing for different body types?
Both carry extended sizes, but ASOS tends to run more inclusive across the range (you'll find more XXS–3XL options). Shopbop is more selective; check individual brand sizing before ordering. Read reviews—they'll note whether something runs small or large.
Are ASOS basics worth it compared to Shopbop?
Yes, but for different reasons. ASOS basics are great for trying silhouettes and seasonal colors without commitment. Shopbop basics (like rag & bone) are built to outlast trends. Buy ASOS for volume and fun; Shopbop for workhorses.
What's the real difference in quality between these two sites?
ASOS prioritizes volume and speed—pieces are made to be affordable and trend-aware, not necessarily built to last 10 years. Shopbop's brands invest in fabric quality, seaming, and construction details. You're paying for longevity and thoughtful design.
Related edits
Whether you're shopping for right now or building something that lasts, know what you're after—and you'll find it. Happy shopping.
Some links may be affiliate links; if you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.