Shopbop vs Mytheresa: Where to Buy Shoes
When you're shopping for shoes online, Shopbop and Mytheresa are two of the best places to look—but they're built for different moods and budgets. Shopbop leans accessible-to-moderate with contemporary labels and a faster refresh. Mytheresa is luxury-focused, curating high-end European designers. Here's what each does best.
Shopbop
Shopbop is a solid place to shop shoes — these are the pieces worth your time.
Loeffler Randall — Gavi Wedge Sandals
Wedge sandals that look expensive without the price tag.
- Best for Summer dinners, resort wear, anywhere you want to look polished without trying.
- Wear it with Pair with a linen midi dress or tailored shorts and a simple tee.
- Fit True to size; leather upper breaks in beautifully over a few wears.
Stuart Weitzman — Rio Sleek 35 Sandals
The sleek sandal that works for everything from brunch to evenings out.
- Best for Someone who wants one excellent neutral sandal that does the heavy lifting.
- Wear it with Works with wide-leg trousers, a slip dress, or even crisp shorts.
- Fit Runs true; narrow heel keeps it elegant without pinching.
Black Suede Studio — Laurel 65 Sandals
Architectural sandals that feel current without chasing trends.
- Best for When you want something a little more interesting than basic but still wearable.
- Wear it with Try with cropped denim or a midi skirt in a neutral tone.
- Fit Comfortable from day one; the strap sits just right across the foot.
Schutz — Vick Buckle Flats
Buckled flats that somehow feel both dressy and easy.
- Best for Office wear, date nights, or whenever you want to look put-together without heels.
- Wear it with Wear with tailored trousers, a midi skirt, or straight-leg jeans.
- Fit Sits close to the foot; padded insole means you can walk all day.
Free People — Zoe Platform Sandals
Platform sandals with bohemian flair at a price that won't sting.
- Best for Festival vibes, casual weekends, anyone drawn to relaxed glamour.
- Wear it with Pair with linen pants, a flowing dress, or vintage denim.
- Fit The platform adds real height without strain; true to size.
Coperni — Belt Ballerina Flats
Ballet flats with architectural precision; they feel like a secret.
- Best for Someone who loves quiet luxury and wants a flat that feels special.
- Wear it with Works with everything—go elegant with tailored trousers or casual with jeans.
- Fit Runs slightly small; size up half a size. The belt detail sits perfectly on the instep.
Mytheresa
Luxury-first curation with European prestige; expect higher prices, rare pieces, and expert styling.
Amina Muaddi Anok Lace Slingback Pumps $1,090
Statement pumps with intricate lace detailing that commands attention.
- Best for Evening wear, cocktail events, when you want your shoes to be the conversation.
- Wear it with Keep the outfit simple—dark trousers or a slip dress lets the shoe shine.
- Fit True to size; the slingback keeps your foot secure despite the delicate front.
Jimmy Choo Elsy Slingback Sandals $875
Slingback sandals with Jimmy Choo's signature polish for evening.
- Best for Weddings, galas, anywhere you want recognizable luxury and serious comfort.
- Wear it with Dress them up with a gown or down with a tailored dress.
- Fit Runs true; cushioned insole makes standing in these all night actually possible.
The Row Ella Leather Mules $1,200
Leather mules that cost the earth and look worth every penny.
- Best for Someone buying an investment piece they'll wear for years; the minimalist with means.
- Wear it with Wear with everything—they're that good. Tailored pants, dresses, jeans all work.
- Fit Runs true; butter-soft leather feels better each time you wear them.
Givenchy Voyou Small Leather Bucket Bag $2,210
A luxury bucket bag that costs more than some shoes but photographs like a dream.
- Best for If you're already splurging and want a bag that signals taste and investment.
- Wear it with Pairs with elevated basics—tailored pieces and quality fabrics elevate it further.
- Fit Structured leather; the strap sits comfortably on the shoulder.
Valentino Garavani VLogo Large Raffia Tote Bag $2,650
A statement raffia tote for summer that costs what a designer piece should.
- Best for The resort-ready wardrobe, beach trips, anyone who views bags as wardrobe anchors.
- Wear it with Let it be the star—keep the rest of your outfit neutral and let the texture sing.
- Fit Spacious enough for a real day; the handles are comfortable for carrying.
Jimmy Choo Isa Snake-Effect Leather Slingback Pumps in Brown $1,050
Snake-effect leather pumps that hit that sweet spot between wild and wearable.
- Best for Pattern lovers who want texture without going full animal print.
- Wear it with Balance the texture with solid pieces—tailored trousers or a simple dress.
- Fit True to size; the slingback ensures the shoe stays put, even on the dance floor.
Shop Jimmy Choo Isa Snake-Effect Leather Slingback Pumps in Brown →
Which should you pick?
Pick Shopbop if you want accessible price points, faster shipping, and contemporary labels that feel fresh. Pick Mytheresa if you're investing in luxury pieces, seeking European prestige, and willing to spend more for rare items and expert curation. Honestly? Many people shop both depending on the mood and the budget that week.
See the full list on Benable
See my full shoes edit on Benable →
Frequently asked questions
Which site has faster shipping?
Shopbop typically ships faster within the US and has easier returns. Mytheresa ships internationally but takes longer; factor in customs if you're outside Europe.
Do these sites do sales or have lower prices?
Shopbop runs regular sales and has a sale section year-round. Mytheresa discounts less frequently but does mark down items seasonally—sign up for alerts if you're patient.
What if the shoe doesn't fit?
Both have good return policies, but Shopbop is more forgiving with free returns. Mytheresa charges for returns in some regions, so read the fine print based on where you live.
Related edits
The right site depends on what you're after: quick, wearable shoes or investment pieces that feel like treasures. Either way, you're in good hands.
Some links may be affiliate links; if you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.